D&D Should Note the Ennies’ AI Ban Impact on TTRPGs

I am thoroughly pleased with the ENNIES’ decision to exclude any works incorporating AI-generated content from their awards. It’s my hope that Wizards of the Coast, the publisher of Dungeons & Dragons, pays careful attention to this development. As a passionate tabletop RPG enthusiast for many years, the increase of AI involvement in TTRPG products—from AI-generated texts to algorithmically created imagery—arouses significant concern. I commend the ENNIE Awards for their ethical stance and hope that Wizards of the Coast will reconsider their approach.

Recent months have seen Hasbro’s AI initiatives stir discontent among D&D fans. The company behind the legendary TTRPG does not seem to grasp the unique essence of this hobby and the anxiety surrounding AI. Issues such as environmental concerns and the appropriation of artistic styles from skilled creators are at the forefront. Many artists and writers strive to earn a living in this field, often encountering daunting challenges. Additionally, AI’s intrusion diminishes the vital human relationships that are the cornerstone of the TTRPG experience.

The Growing Dilemma of AI Art and Writing in TTRPGs

Publishers Cutting Corners: A Threat to the TTRPG Community

Regular visitors to platforms like DriveThruRPG can easily observe the alarming influx of products adorned with AI-generated art and accompanied by text produced through Large Language Models (LLMs).The ENNIE Awards, which honor various TTRPG systems—including D&D 5e—have set a precedent. If Wizards of the Coast does not adjust its strategy, there stands a genuine risk that D&D publications may become ineligible for these prestigious awards. The ENNIEs represent the highest accolades within the tabletop RPG community, and their recent policy, effective from the 2025-2026 submission cycle, sends a clear message.

Although some argue that AI art democratizes TTRPGs, indie creators have alternative options, including forgoing art altogether or sourcing reasonably priced stock illustrations, readily available on the same platforms.

During a recent meeting, CEO Chris Cocks expressed excitement about the “playful elements”of AI, noting that in his groups of 30 to 40 players, everyone reportedly utilizes AI in some capacity for campaign and character development. This dubious assertion deserves scrutiny, highlighting yet again why fans should remain apprehensive.

The Heart of TTRPGs: Human Connection

Using AI for Artistic or Literary Contributions Undermines TTRPG’s Communal Nature

Tabletop RPGs thrive on the interplay between players and storytelling—much like the cooperative narratives explored in “Star Trek’s” utopian vision. Within the ‘Roddenberry future, ’ humanity is depicted as self-sufficient and exploring the galaxy harmoniously, yet it is perplexing that AI has started to engage most with creative professions such as art, writing, and music.

Even though indie TTRPGs celebrating community may represent a niche, the overarching essence of the hobby hinges on these communal principles. Players immerse themselves in characters, and Game Masters weave intricate narratives, bringing life to the experiences shared among their peers. This unique interactivity distinguishes TTRPGs from their video game counterparts, showcasing that the bonds formed during gameplay are what truly elevate the experience.

Presently, DriveThruRPG allows authors to self-disclose any use of AI in their work’s creation, leading to many submissions being labeled “Creation Method Not Chosen By Publisher.”In contrast, the ENNIE Awards will require a strict adherence to their new guideline: “Creators wishing to submit products must guarantee that no AI-generated elements are part of their work.”

Even though several indie TTRPGs revolve around letter writing, at their core, all RPGs emphasize communication. Not only does it involve the engagement of players within the game world, but it also encompasses the connection between authors and their audience. Writers convey the themes and emotions integral to the RPG experience, while illustrators enrich the visual narrative.In essence, the rules of TTRPGs are a medium of communication between humans.

D&D Must Align with Ethical Standards Concerning AI

TTRPG Communities Stand Firm Against AI in Creative Expression

Wizards of the Coast CEO Chris Cocks has indicated plans to enhance D&D’s online platforms by integrating tools for “AI-driven emergent storytelling, ”which raises the unsettling prospect of monetizing AI to replace human Dungeon Masters.

Wizards of the Coast, the dominant force in the TTRPG market, could potentially venture into the perilous territory of AI Dungeon, should Cocks’s visions materialize. Such a move could lead to the sidelining of artists and writers, as corporations pursue profit through AI-driven creations. While TTRPGs foster communication between players and Game Masters, they also bind authors and artists to their audience. The ENNIE Awards have made a commendable, though necessary, ethical commitment, yet Dungeons & Dragons may ultimately lean towards a profit-driven model.

Sources: ENNIES, Futurism, TGN – Tabletop Gaming News/YouTube

Source & Images

Related Articles:

Borderlands 4: Key Details and Updates on the Next Installation of the Iconic Looter Shooter

Nintendo Acknowledges Frame Rate Issues in Donkey Kong Bananza

Weekend PC Game Deals: Final Fantasy at Low Prices, Bundled Borderlands Offers, and Free Strategy Games

Electronic Arts May Have Paused the Need for Speed Franchise

Chris Evans 2011 Interview Reveals Hypocrisy Behind Anthony Mackie’s Recent Captain America Backlash

D&D’s New Spell Mechanic Could Be Its Most Overpowered Change to Date

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *