Elden Ring Fans Are Debating Shadow Of The Erdtree's Worst Spell

Summary

• Rotten Butterflies and Rain of Fire are battling it out for the title of worst spell in Elden Ring's Shadow of the Erdtree DLC.
• Fans argue that both don't do enough damage, cost too much FP, and take too much time to cast.
• Minor Erdtree and Midra's Flame of Frenzy are also mentioned as underwhelming incantations, even if they are kind of important to Elden Ring lore.

Elden Ring has a wide variety of tools to take down the horrors of The Lands Between, sorceries and incantations being very helpful against almost every enemy in the game. Shadow of the Erdtree unsurprisingly adds even more spells to our arsenals, including the excellent and powerful Rellana's Twin Moons, but for every great spell, there's a pretty rubbish one that isn't worth the FP you spend casting it.

Elden Ring fans have been talking about what they think the worst spell in the DLC is, with Reddit user Choice_Car_7934 making a strong opening case for Rotten Butterflies. Even though you get the incantation by trading in the Remembrance of a certain boss, it is nowhere near as potent as its flashy aesthetic makes it appear, and does middling damage for far too much FP. Another user called PacosBigTacos even admits that it "might as well be an emote for me."

Rotten Butterflies has plenty of competition though, and another very popular shout for Shadow of the Erdtree's worst spell is Rain of Fire, which Reddit user AwryShark claims to have seen "barely chunking a wild deer." It's also made worse by the fact that base Elden Ring has an incantation called Founding Rain of Stars which is almost the same thing and just as bad, and there are some people that even think the spell is bugged.

Minor Erdtree and Midra's Flame of Frenzy Are Also Named Shadow Of The Erdtree's Worst Spells

While Rotten Butterflies and Rain of Fire are duking it out for first place, there are a bunch of other rather underwhelming spells that Elden Ring fans have issues with, one of them being Minor Erdtree. Sure, it has major connections to the game's lore, but as an actual incantation to use in battle, Reddit user TinyPigdenofDoom just thinks it's a fancy version of Warmth that requires way too much FP to use. It's not particularly impressive either, since Melina can summon a bigger one, as user Careless-Ad-20 calls ours "a bush at best."

Midra's Flame of Frenzy is also an incantation mentioned by TinyPigdenofDoom and a couple of other users, mainly because of its long cast time, FP cost, and the fact that it inflicts the user with frenzy before its true potential comes out. Another user called Lunesy is also pretty disappointed that it functions quite similarly to other frenzy incantations, despite all the fancy moves Midra himself uses in the fight against you.

It's also quite telling that all of these inclusions are incantations, with barely a single sorcery mentioned in the entire thread. I guess that goes to show you how much of a mixed bag it can be using incantations. Thankfully, my big brain frost mage is eating well, so I'll be pounding enemies into the dirt with my Ranni and Rellana two punch combo.

Baldur's Gate 3 Isn't A Live-Service Game. Stop Treating It Like One.

Baldur's Gate 3's latest patch adds a temporary companion and changes a dark Astarion moment into fanfiction