MLB The Show 24 Best Center Fielders, Ranked

Summary

• Centerfield is considered the hardest outfield position in baseball due to the enormous area to cover.
• Players like Jose Siri showcase elite defense and baserunning skills over hitting metrics in MLB The Show 24.
• Top-rated center fielders like Julio Rodriguez and Mike Trout emphasize hitting prowess in the game.

Out of the three outfield positions, its center field which acknowledged as the “hardest”. The sheer amount of area for players to cover, coupled with their general role as outfield leaders, makes center field one of the most crucial positions in baseball. As such, only truly gifted ballplayers are trusted to maintain that green.

MLB The Show 24: Best Overall Players, Ranked

Home run hitters, high-rated players, MLB The Show 24 has it all, but which player comes out on top?

What makes a great center fielder is malleable. Some center fielders may struggle with the bat, but sport elite caliber speed. Others may not be as swift, but their immaculate defense necessities their presence in the lineup for every game. These ten center fielders are the best of the best you can find in MLB The Show 24.

10 Jose Siri

Overall: 83

While it’s standard in the modern MLB for your centerfielder to be as adept with the bat as they were with the glove, that wasn’t always the case, since teams of the past used to prioritize speed and defense over hitting. Even if that’s not completely accurate with Jose Siri, there’s no doubt what he’s best at.

The Tampa Bay Rays center fielder makes up for his decent hitting metrics with lightning-quick baserunning and savvy defense. His 83 overall is a testament to how prized Siri’s hotshot defense and base running when contrast with his slightly above-average hitting.

9 Jazz Chisholm Jr.

Overall: 83

There isn’t much for fans to be happy about regarding the Miami Marlins. Best known for breaking down their team after every successful season, it seems likely that the Miami faithful are in for another season of pain, but that’s not to say there aren’t any bright spots.

The cover star of MLB The Show 23 Jazz Chisholm Jr. continues to establish himself as the Marlins’ most dynamic and charismatic player. With an 83 overall in MLB The Show 24, Jazz Chisholm Jr. features decent pop, solid fielding, good speed, and the ability to play several positions.

8 Byron Buxton

Overall: 84

With their most successful season in two decades behind them, the future looks encouraging for the Minnesota Twins. Even with the torrent of young prospect and respected veterans, their most well-known play remains center fielder and Twin’s mainstay Byron Buxton.

MLB The Show 24: Best Shortstops, Ranked

One of the most important positions on the baseball diamond, we rank some of the best shortstops in MLB The Show 24.

In real life, Buxton is known for his susceptibility to injury, but when he is healthy, there are few players more productive in all of MLB. Buxton is a menace both on the base paths and the plate with remarkable power and speed; Buxton’s also an excellent defender, well deserving of an 84 overall.

7 Cody Bellinger

Overall: 88

When Cody Bellinger signed a one-year deal with the Chicago Cubs before the 2023 season, it was a low-risk high-reward move for a player seemingly past their prime thanks to injury and inconsistent play. Few could’ve foreseen just how great Bellinger would be for Chicago’s team.

Bellinger’s 88 overall makes him the highest-rated Chicago Cub in MLB The Show 24. Bellinger is a blend of strong hitting and even better fielding, and since he's returning to the Cubs for the 2024 season, many are excited to see if the former MVP can keep his momentum going.

6 Luis Robert Jr.

Overall: 89

To say the Chicago White Sox rebuild failed is an understatement; after a mere two years of contention, the wheels completely fell off for Chicago’s second most famous baseball team. Even with most of their prospects turning out to be duds, there was one diamond in the rough.

Luis Robert Jr. is the only member of the White Sox’s young core who actually reached his potential. Rated at an extremely strong 89 overall thanks to high hitting and fielding numbers, Robert Jr. serves as the sole silver lining for this blight of an alleged MLB franchise.

5 Michael Harris II

Overall: 89

The Atlanta Braves are going to be a very good team for a very long time; not only are they brimming with all-star quality players are every position, but they also have signed most of them to lengthy contract extensions. One of the newer signings was that of Michael Harris II.

MLB The Show 24: Best Catchers, Ranked

These catchers are the best in MLB The Show 24.

Michael Harris II maintains elite contact, baserunning, and fielding, all while reinforced by one of the best lineups in baseball. Given his age and high ceiling, it’s easy to imagine that his 89 overall rating in MLB The Show 24 will see a sharp upsurge in following entries in San Diego Studio’s baseball series.

4 Corbin Carroll

Overall: 91

Arguably, the single best base runner in baseball, Arizona Diamondbacks’ Corbin Caroll was an instrumental piece of their unexpected 2023 postseason run. Even though they fell to the Texas Rangers in the World Series, there’s reason to be optimistic about the Diamondbacks and their star player.

Corbin’s 91 overall is impressive for any rookie, but what’s even more extraordinary is him having a 99 overall in all baserunning categories. So as long as you get Caroll on base in MLB The Show 24, you have free rein to run wild and steal bases to your heart’s content.

3 Julio Rodriguez

Overall: 93

It’s been a long time since the Seattle Mariners fans had hope. But after breaking their two-decade-long playoff drought in 2022, many believe that this crop of young players will bring Seattle to even greater glory in the not-to-distant future.

At the head of that movement is twenty-three-year-old center fielder Julio Rodriguez, who has already proved himself as the future of Mariner’s baseball. At a 93 overall in MLB The Show 24, Rodriguez exhibits exemplary hitting metrics along with outstanding baserunning and superior defense. Again, he’s only twenty-three.

2 Aaron Judge

Overall: 99

The New York Yankees finished the 2023 MLB season with an 82-80 record, their worst record since 1992. There are many places where the finger of blame can point to the Yankees missing out on the October dance, but one spot that can’t be blamed is center field.

MLB The Show 24: Best Pitchers, Ranked

Fill that crucial pitcher spot with our tier list of the best around in MLB The Show 24.

Aaron Judge has become the captain of the Yankees after signing a huge contract in the 2023 offseason, and few players hit the ball as hard and as far as the Yankee’s center fielder. With 99 ratings in both power categories and plate discipline, suffice to say, Judge is one of the select few modern players to be given the prestigious 99 overall.

1 Mike Trout

Overall: 99

Of course, the greatest player of this generation of MLB is rated at a 99 overall. Los Angeles Angels centerfielder Mike Trout deserves nothing less than the absolute highest rating possible. While his lack of postseason success has earned him wrongful criticism, that has done little to hurt Trout’s legacy.

Even with his recent battles with injuries, Trout has already earned a plaque in Cooperstown when his career is said and done. Trout may not be the baserunner or defender he used to be, but with hitting skills like he has, there’s no question that he’s the best center fielder in MLB The Show 24.

MLB The Show 24: 10 Best Teams, Ranked

From the Orioles to the Dodgers, we rank the best teams you can find in MLB The Show 24.