MLB The Show 24: Best Overall Players, Ranked

Summary

• MLB The Show 24 features star players like Guerrero Jr but highlights top talent like Ohtani, Seager, Acuna at high ratings.
• Top-rated MLB The Show 24 player, Shohei Ohtani, showcases elite versatility and dominance for any team with 99 overall.
• Players like Aaron Judge, Mookie Betts, and Mike Trout in MLB The Show 24 prove to be integral home run hitters and top-rated athletes.

MLB The Show 24 proves to be a perfect game to play in time with a new season of baseball. The cover star for MLB The Show 24 is Toronto Blue Jays first baseman Vladimir Guerrero Jr. While Guerrero Jr. is unquestionably a talented hitter, he’s not the MLB’s best player.

12 Best Baseball Video Games

There are so many different baseball games, narrowing down the best ones is a challenge.

In MLB The Show 24, there are several players who rate much higher than the son of Hall of Famer Vladimir Guerrero. There’s no doubt that San Diego Studio will add more players into the game as the season progresses, but these ten superstars represent the best of the best in MLB The Show 24.

10 Gerrit Cole

Overall: 95

When you ask someone who doesn’t watch baseball to name an MLB team, more likely than not, they’ll say the New York Yankees. Most well known for throwing sacks of money at players and their ridiculous no facial hair policy, the Yankees also boast one of the league’s best pitchers in Gerrit Cole.

Even though Cole’s time thus far in New York has featured some controversy and accusations of doctoring baseball spin rates, the man with the three hundred twenty million dollar arm sports an impressive 96 overall in MLB The Show 24.

9 Austin Riley

Overall: 96

The Atlanta Braves have become one of the MLB’s juggernaut squads. Between their flock of young talent and pension for locking up their best players to multi-year extensions, there’s no shortage of great ballplayers in A-Town.

Third baseman Austin Riley is just one player who will be in Atlanta for years to come. At a 96, Riley is the highest rated third baseman in the entire game. A hitting savant, Riley is the premiere choice in MLB The Show 24 for the hot corner.

8 Yordan Alvarez

Overall: 96

The Houston Astros have been a thorn in the side of the American League for the better part of a decade. While they likely wouldn’t have won the 2017 World Series without their elaborate cheating system, there’s no denying the Astros feature plenty of stars.

MLB The Show 24: How To Hit The Ball Better

Learn how to improve your at bats in MLB The Show 24.

Yordan Alvarez is perhaps the most intimidating batter in Astros lineup. The left-handed slugger has a 96 overall in MLB The Show 24, the highest of any Astros player. If you’re looking for a massive home run threat, Alvarez fits the bill.

7 Spencer Strider

Overall: 97

The recent years of baseball have seen a sharp upsurge in strikeouts. As MLB hitters change their approach towards home runs, walks, and extra bases, strikeouts have subsequently skyrocketed. There is no pitcher in baseball more efficient at getting whiffs than Spencer Strider.

Sadly, Strider has recently suffered an injury that threatens to derail his season. But last year, Strider was raking up strikeouts with disquieting ease. He may not be the consensus best pitcher in real life, but at a 97 overall, he’s the best pitcher in MLB The Show 24.

6 Corey Seager

Overall: 98

The 2023 Texas Rangers made history when they took home their franchise’s first World Series championship. The formula for the Ranger’s triumph in the Fall Classic came down to their mix of superstars and young up and comers. At the front of the pack is Corey Seager.

Winner of 2023 World Series MVP award, Corey Seager has become one of the best hitters in the league. Sporting a 98 overall rating, Seager just misses that thin air space at the top of MLB The Shows rating system. Nonetheless, he’s an absolute hitting stud.

5 Shohei Ohtani

Overall: 99

There is so much to say about the Dodger’s Shohei Ohtani, from his monster contract (nearly all of which is deferred), his mastery of hitting and pitching, and the recent sports betting fiasco he’s become a part of (allegedly), Ohtani is no doubt one of baseball’s most talked about icons.

10 Games To Play If You Like MLB: The Show 24

More of the best games for the baseball lovers.

Whatever you may feel about Ohtani, he’s unquestionably the most valuable player in all of baseball. With a 99 overall, Ohtani is an exceedingly versatile and dominant player, a perfect fit for any ball club.

4 Ronald Acuna Jr.

Overall: 99

As star-loaded the Atlanta Braves are top from bottom with names like Matt Olson, Sean Murphy, Ozzie Albies, and Austin Riley, there’s no debate about which player is the face of their franchise. That player would be multi-all-star outfielder Ronald Acuna Jr.

Acuna has been a superstar since coming into the league at the age of twenty. With a 99 overall, he is one of the highest-rated players in MLB The Show 24 and a perfect choice for anybody to put in their outfield.

3 Aaron Judge

Overall: 99

It’s truly surprising that despite featuring some of the best players in all of baseball, the New York Yankees have circled the label of mediocrity throughout the past several years, not making a World Series for over a decade.

99 overall outfielder Aaron Judge is just another superbly talented ballplayer who dawned the pinstripes. Even as the rest of the team underwhelms around him, Judge continues to establish himself as the quintessential home run hitter in MLB.

2 Mookie Betts

Overall: 99

There’s perhaps no better athlete in the MLB than the Dodger’s Mookie Betts. Not only has Mookie proven himself as an extraordinary hitter but also one of the finest defenders in the entire league.

MLB The Show 24: Best Throwing Interface To Use

Find the best throwing mechanics for you and start turning double plays!

Now playing shortstop for the Dodgers, Betts continues to play elite-level defense at every position he’s slotted in. A 99 overall seems only right for the multi-time all-star, gold glover, former MVP, and World Series champion, not to mention his expertise as a bowler.

1 Mike Trout

Overall: 99

Well, all know the saying, “In this world, nothing can be said to be certain except death and taxes.” It might be high time to add “Mike Trout crushing baseballs” to that idiom. He remains one of the greatest players to ever step onto a baseball diamond.

Despite middling records and injuries, Mike Trout continues to be the only thing keeping the Angels relevant. His 99 overall is well deserved for Trout who continues to prove himself as one of the best MLB players of all time.

The Best Baseball Games On Nintendo Switch

These baseball games hit a home run on the Nintendo Switch.