Abigail is pretty easy to please in terms of gifts in Stardew Valley, and a good rule of thumb is that if it’s purple, she’ll probably love it. In the past, if you gave her Quartz, she would eat it. Thankfully, her teeth are no longer in danger as this no longer seems to be the case, but it still lives on as a meme in the community. 

Recommended Videos

Anyway, moving past her penchant for rocking-eating, Abigail is a fan favorite. If you want to get close to her, or even marry her and move her into your farmhouse, you’ll need to know what she likes. 

Universal Loved and Liked Gifts in Stardew Valley

Image by Destructoid

Some Stardew Valley gifts are beloved by everyone in the village, excluding a few pickier folks like Penny or Haley. While universally loved may be a little harder to come by, universally liked is pretty easy, and Abigail accepts most things. If you need more places to offload the universal goodies to, look to others like Sebastian, Penny, or Marnie.

Universally loved gifts for Abigail:

  • Stardrop Tea
    • Additional benefit of being able to give another, secondary gift
  • Golden Pumpkin
  • Magic Rock Candy
  • Pearl
  • Prismatic Shard (except Haley)
  • Rabbit’s Foot (except Penny)

Universally liked gifts for Abigail:

  • All artisan goods (except for Oil and Void Mayonnaise)
  • All cooking (except Fried Egg, Bread, Strange Bun, and Seafoam Pudding)
  • All flowers (except Poppy)
  • All fruit tree fruits (except Banana and Mango)
  • All vegetables (except Hops, Tea Leaves, Wheat, and Unmilled Rice)
  • All foraged minerals (except Quartz, but some villagers still like it)
  • All gems
  • Life Elixir
  • Maple Syrup
  • Pina Colada
  • Rainbow Shell
  • Treasure Chest

What does Abigal like in Stardew Valley?

Image by Destructoid

Abigail loves all of the universally loved gifts, so if you’ve got a Rabbit’s Foot lying around or you’ve just received the Golden Pumpkin as part of the Spirit’s Eve festival, she’s going to be happy to receive them. If you want to make things more personal, Abigail loves getting the following:

GiftHow to get AmethystFound when breaking nodes in the Mines or QuarryBanana PuddingCooked using the following recipe:
1 Banana
1 Milk
1 SugarBlackberry CobblerCooked using the following recipe:
2 Blackberries
1 Sugar
1 Wheat FlourChocolate CakeCooked using the following recipe:
1 Wheat Flour
1 Sugar
1 EggMonster CompendiumFound by killing monsters
Purchased at the Bookseller from year 3 onwards for 20,000 GoldPufferfishCaught by fishing on Ginger IslandPumpkinGrown in FallSpicy EelCooked using the following recipe:
1 Eel
1 Hot Pepper

Abigail’s liked gifts in Stardew Valley

Abigail likes most of the universally liked gifts, but she isn’t a fan of eating her vegetables, so giving her any veggies won’t do much for your relationship. I guess she prefers harder things to munch on. She also likes:

GiftHow to get Ancient SwordFound by digging up artifact spotsBasilisk PawRandom drop from killing emeniesBone FluteFound by digging up artifact spotsCombat QuarterlyPurchased from the Bookseller for 5,000 to 10,000 Gold
Purchased from the Traveling Cart for 6,000 Gold
Fishing treasure chests
Mayor Lewis’ Prize Machine
Found in the Mines
Digging up artifact spotsQuartzFound in the Mines Post Tag: ConcernedApe guides Stardew Valley Destructoid is supported by our audience. When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn a small affiliate commission. Learn more about our Affiliate Policy Join The Conversation